Audrey enjoyed an outstanding career at Valley Forge, lettering in volleyball, basketball and softball. She was a three time All-Lake Erie League selection in volleyball and softball and was recognized as All-Lake Erie League in basketball in 1985. Audrey was league Most Valuable Player in 1984 when the Patriots won the Lake Erie League title. Audrey was selected as the Valley Forge Outstanding Female Athlete in 1985.
While at John Carroll University, Audrey was a four time All-League selection in basketball and team Most Valuable Player in 1989. In softball, she was a three-time league Most Valuable Player and led all Division III schools in batting average as a junior and senior. She was chosen to the John Carroll University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1999.