Andy lettered in football, basketball and track during all three years at Valley Forge. He was recognized as All-Lake Erie League, Lake Erie League Most Valuable Player and both Cleveland Press and Plain Dealer All-Scholastic teams while playing safety and running back. Andy set several Valley Forge rushing records as a senior He also played in the North-South All-Star Game. Andy was selected as the 1979 Outstanding Patriot Athlete.
While at the University of Kentucky, Andy was a four year defensive back starter and was selected All-SEC in 1981. He was the Wildcat team captain in 1982 and played in three post season All-Star games.
Andy has been coaching football for several years.