A three-sport athlete at Parma, Cicerchi earned three letters in football, three in baseball and one in wrestling.  A two-time All-LEL selection in football, he is the most prolific tackler in PSH school history.  His senior season, he set the school record for tackles and sacks and also was the leading tackler in the state of Ohio.  He finished his PSH career with over 400 tackles. His tackling records still stand today. 

Cicerchi was a three-year letterman at Edinboro University, where he continued to be a dominant force on defense.  He led the Fighting Scots in tackles his junior and senior campaigns and ranks amongst their all-time tackling leaders.  A multiple All-Conference selection in college, Cicerchi earned AP Little All-American honors as well. 

He was inducted into the Edinboro University Athletic Hall of Fame in 2007.